Historical Cultures in Transition: Negotiating Memory, History and Identity in the Contemporary Central and Eastern Europe
Research theme: Public History and the City: Engaging and Reflecting the Pasts

Historical Cultures in Transition: Negotiating Memory, History and Identity in the Contemporary Central and Eastern Europe

facebook icon twitter icon email icon telegram icon link icon whatsapp icon

Dr. Sofia Dyak, Dr. Natalia Otrishchenko, Dr. Vasyl Rasevych, Dr. Iryna Sklokina

The research focused on transformations within the historical cultures of Poland and Ukraine over the past two decades. It aimed to clarify the structure, content, and internal mechanisms that operate in the areas of historical production and cultural heritage. The project took into account the perspectives of various actors in this field: experts and institutions that create historical knowledge, media that broadcast it, education that systematically transmits it between generations, and citizens of both countries who interact with the past in different ways. The study focused on how politics in these countries use images of the past to gain public support, and legitimize or delegitimize the political order. Finally, we sought to understand the differences and similarities between the historical cultures of Poland and Ukraine in the broader comparative context of Central and Eastern Europe.

In order to study the extent of human participation in what we can call the "daily functioning of history", in 2018 we conducted representative surveys in both countries. To understand what historical canon is reflected in the school curriculum (as in one of the most important spaces where the state manifests its own attitude to the past), we analyzed textbooks and recorded focus group discussions with history teachers in eight Ukrainian and eight Polish cities and towns. In addition, we conducted expert interviews and worked with cases of historic towns – it was a kind of "laboratory" where the policies of various actors and institutions are intertwined.

An important component of the project was the study of the functioning of images from the past in the public sphere. We analyzed the media, online platforms, and public and scientific discourses that operate in both countries. Thus, the study combined multiple perspectives – from citizens’ engagement with the past of both countries to academic historical debates, from the dissemination of images of the past in the media to their instrumentalization in the political sphere. As a result, we proposed a methodology for analyzing historical culture as a whole.

The project is organized within the frame of OPUS contest of the Polish National Center of Science (UMO-2016/21/B/HS3/03415). It is conducted by Collegium Civitas in cooperation with the Institute of Political Studies Polish Academy of Science. The head of the project: dr hab. Tomasz Stryjek, prof. ISP PAN. Implementation period - 2017-2020 years. More information about this research could be found at the website.

Related publications and presentations

The Politics of Memory in Poland and Ukraine: From Reconciliation to De-Conciliation. Eds . Tomasz Stryjek, Joanna Konieczna-Sałamatin. Routledge, 2021. https://www.routledge.com/The-Politics-of-Memory-in-Poland-and-Ukraine-From-Reconciliation-to-De-Conciliation/Stryjek-Konieczna-Salamatin/p/book/9780367861728 .

Cultures of Historical Poland and Ukraine. About the sources of misunderstanding among neighbors. Red. Tomasz Stryjek, Volodymyr Sklokin. ISP PAN - Scholar, Warsaw 2021. https://scholar.com.pl/pl/glowna/4245-kultury-historyczne-polski-i-ukrainy.html The book is available in the library of the Center.

Historical discourse in the mass media. Representations of the past in the Polish and Ukrainian spheres of media. Red. Barbara Markowska. ISP PAN - CC - Scholar, Warsaw 2021. https://scholar.com.pl/pl/glowna/4237-dyskurs-historyczny-w-mediach-masowych.html The book is available in the library of the Center.

Marek Wojnar, Walka o pamięć czy instrumentalizacja historii: intelektualiści wobec polityki pamięci w III Rzeczypospolitej i na Ukrainie. ISP PAN, Warszawa 2021. https://wydawnictwo.isppan.waw.pl/produkt/walka-o-pamiec-czy-instrumentalizacja-historii-intelektualisci-wobec-polityki-pamieci-w-iii-rzeczypospolitej-i-na- ukraine/

Report on the results of a quantitative sociological survey conducted in Poland and Ukraine in 2018: in Ukrainian, Polish, English.

Related events

Historical cultures of Poland and Ukraine: about sources of (mis)understanding between neighbors

Credits

Сover Image: Opening of the photo exhibition by Tadeusz Rolke "Tomorrow Will Be Better," Eugene Chervonyi, 2016.



Other research focuses

Cities, Wars, and Recoveries in 20th Century Eastern Europe

Cities, Wars, and Recoveries in 20th Century Eastern Europe

This focus incorporates the history of the cities and towns in the eastern parts of Europe, both on and behind the front lines, during periods of belligerence and post-war recovery.

Details
Documenting Experiences of War

Documenting Experiences of War

We have involved our capacity and expertise to document the experiences of Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine as historical and/or legal evidence, but also as a way to withstand the invasion.

Details
Professionals, Expertise, and Planned Urbanity

Professionals, Expertise, and Planned Urbanity

This focus on planned cities, towns, and districts in socialist societies explores the visions of planners, experts, and decision-makers, who were all involved in the construction and experience of planned urbanity.

Details
The Social City: Histories of Mobility, Status, Gender and Welfare

The Social City: Histories of Mobility, Status, Gender and Welfare

This research focus extends the established approaches to the history of modern Lviv, centered on the history of the formation of national communities, by addressing other categories of social divisions: gender, age, class, and group.

Details
Urban Cultural Infrastructures: Creators, Managers, Audiences in the Modern City

Urban Cultural Infrastructures: Creators, Managers, Audiences in the Modern City

This research focus aims to expand our understanding of the ways infrastructures shape creative culture in the modern city.

Details
Urban Heritages: Concepts, Practices and Legacies

Urban Heritages: Concepts, Practices and Legacies

This research focus incorporates several individual projects, as well as initiatives in cooperation that analyze heritage both as a set of concepts, discourses, and practices, as well as institutional and discursive frames.

Details
Visual Regimes, Materialities, and Technologies

Visual Regimes, Materialities, and Technologies

This research focus is related to visual practices and historical or social ways of seeing. Within it, we focus on the study of historical changes in technology, imagination, and politics, and how they influence the transformation of visual practices and sensibilities.

Details